Leading medics have raised concerns that people are being “overdiagnosed” with obesity, calling for a “reframing” of the way the condition is diagnosed. Academics argue that a body mass index (BMI) score is not “nuanced” enough to measure obesity and more assessments are needed before someone is told they are obese.
They suggest that solely using BMI can lead to both overestimates and underestimates of the number of obese people. For example, some individuals may be very active and experience no ill-effects from their weight but are still classified as obese.
Meanwhile, others may be suffering significant harm because of obesity, such as problems with their internal organs. A new Lancet Commission – comprising more than 50 experts from around the world – has called for a “radical overhaul” in the diagnosis of obesity.
READ MORE: Parents may be ‘fuelling obesity’ by encouraging one eating habit in children
READ MORE: Woman loses incredible amount of weight after ‘one lifestyle change’
They say that “BMI is useful but we need to go beyond BMI to determine excess body fat” and that the measurement tool should only be used as a “surrogate measure of health risk”. The commission suggests that obesity should only be diagnosed using BMI when clinicians also take other measurements such as waist to hip ratio or waist to height ratio.
Ideally, obesity would be measured using total body fat, but the academics acknowledge that this would involve clinics “going beyond” what they would usually do to identify obese people because it can include more expensive and time-consuming body scans. The researchers have proposed two new “diagnostic categories” of obesity.
Clinical obesity is defined as a “chronic systematic illness” where excess fat can lead to organ damage and potentially life-threatening complications. Pre-clinical obesity, on the other hand, is described as a “state of excess adiposity” where the individual has a variable level of health risk but no ongoing illness.
The authors noted that there has been a “polarised” debate about whether obesity should be classified as an illness, and these new definitions aim to provide some clarity.
Join our WhatsApp Top Stories and, Breaking News group by clicking this link
Professor Francesco Rubino, chairman of the commission and chairman of metabolic and bariatric surgery at King’s College London, said: “Some people who are today classified as having obesity by BMI (but) they might play sports, they’re very active, they might have very strong bones – saying that those people have obesity and then classifying them as having a disease would obviously be an overdiagnosis.
“This commission has been trying to deal with a more accurate way of diagnosing and classifying obesity in the first place.” No system – the NHS or others – have had these methods yet – I think everybody has been using the old classification for four decades, at least.
“But we are calling for a change, a radical change, because obviously, in the context of one billion people being classified as having obesity in the world today, and with a number that is projected to increase, no country is rich enough to be able to afford inaccuracy in the diagnosis of obesity.”
He added: “The message remains that obesity can be a health risk. What we’re proposing is to say that ‘it’s not only a health risk, for some it is actually an illness and that needs to be diagnosed’. And I think it’s sensible to understand what is this level of risk to decide what is the best course of action?
“If we were to give exactly the same intervention to everybody who has obesity – we have a billion people (with obesity) and you have to give the same intervention to everybody.
“Not only is (this) probably economically unsustainable, but it’s also not exactly what each individual needs, because the personalised care is what makes the effectiveness and (the) cost effectiveness of the interventions. And so we cannot afford having a blurry picture of obesity.”
The comments come against the backdrop of the NHS starting the rollout of weight loss jabs for obese individuals meeting certain criteria. In 2022, the government said obesity costs the NHS £6 billion every year, a figure which is expected to rise to more than £9.7 billion each year by 2050.
Recent figures from the Health Survey for England indicate that around 29% of adults in England are classified as obese. Also noteworthy are the statistics that demonstrate 15% of children aged two to 15 across England are considered obese, according to the survey.
Discussing the National Childhood Measurement Programme, which gauges childhood obesity levels by calculating BMI from height and weight, Professor Louise Baur, University of Sydney’s chair in child and adolescent health, endorsed the initiative, saying: “I’m just very pleased that actually, height and weight are actually being measured in children and young people because it’s a great measure of linear growth of failure to thrive, of overweight and multiple other things.
“So if paediatric people stop measuring height and weight, I think that’s almost the death of paediatrics to some extent – growth is part of childhood and abnormalities and growth are actually part of highlighting health problems.”
Commenting on the commission, Dr Kath McCullough, special adviser on obesity at the Royal College of Physicians, said: “For too long, we’ve relied on BMI as a simple measure of obesity, which has often misrepresented the condition and fails to fully reflect how excess body fat impacts a person’s health.
“The commission’s distinction between pre-clinical and clinical obesity represents a vital step forward, highlighting the need to identify and intervene early while providing appropriate care to those already experiencing severe health impacts.”
Katharine Jenner, director of the Obesity Health Alliance, focused on the real-world implications: “Our priority should be supporting those living with excess weight, rather than focusing solely on how it is measured.
“Currently, obesity treatment is inaccessible to those who need it most, namely individuals with the highest levels of excess weight, while our prevention policies remain insufficient.”
An NHS England spokesperson said: “Nice (the National Institute for Health and Care Excellence) has published updated guidance regarding the identification, assessment, treatment and personalised care of people who are overweight or living with obesity.
“Nice independently assesses the evidence and NHS England follows the guidance as published.”