ITV Love Island All Stars winners ‘revealed’ already as fans all say same thing

Love Island: All Stars has returned and fans are convinced they’ve already worked out who will win the 2025 series.

Presenter Maya Jama was back on our screens on Monday (January 13) to host the second series of the Love Island spin-off and the opening episode didn’t dissapoint.

She welcomed Curtis Pritchard, Luca Bish, India Reynolds, Marcel Somerville, Elma Pazar, Catherine Agbaje, Olivia Hawkins, Ronnie Vint, Scott Thomas, Gabby Allen, Kaz Crossley and Nas Majeed back to the villa but there was a twist.

Before the sext singletons got to couple up, they each played a ‘spicy” ice-breaker game. As the boys stood in front of the fire pit, Maya explained: “I have a bucket of red flags here and the game is simple. Girls, one at a time I want you to hand a red flag to one of the boys that you think deserves it most and explain why.

Love Island viewers have hailed Curtis Pritchard and Catherine Agbaje -Credit:ITV/REX/Shutterstock

READ MORE: ITV Love Island All Stars viewers distracted by Curtis Pritchard’s ‘serious glow up’

READ MORE: Love Island All Stars on ITV: When and what time it is it on and line-up in full for 2025 series

“It could be based on what you already know about each other, maybe you’ve got some previous history or first impressions.”

As explosive game came to an end, Maya dropped a bomshell on the Islanders. She revealed: “The decision of who you couple up with is not down to you. The public have already coupled you up.”

The boys lined up in front of the fire pit before the ice-breaker game -Credit:ITV

However before Maya revealed the results of the public vote, fans admitted they’d already picked their winners. Taking to X, formerly known as Twitter, one fan penned: “Catherine and Curtis already giving winners before anyone else is in there #LoveIsland #LoveIslandAllStars.”

Another added: “My winners walked in together btw.” A third person said: “Catherine and Curtis connecting and ignoring Maya is so funny but I kinda like the vibe between them hold on lol #LoveIsland.”

Maya Jama welcomed 12 sexy singletons back to the villa -Credit:ITV

A fourth social media user agreed: “Not they leaked the winners like this???” alongside a picture of Curtis and Catherine together.

Fans will have to wait and see who will follow in Tom Clare and Molly Smith’s footsteps and be crowned champions.

Love Island All Stars airs Sunday to Thursday on ITV2 and ITVX at 9pm